Plum Island Horror: More of a Bad Thing

Marsoni

M251S

$74.89

Get it in 3 business days with 1 day shipping. Friday, May 29

Plum Island Horror: More of a Bad ThingWell, well, wellyou just couldnt get enough of The Plum Island Horror, could you? And now you went and asked for more stuff. Well, to quote AC DC, if you want blood, you got it. Despite my better judgment, the GMT bigwigs have harassed, cudgeled, and shamed me into emerging from my quiet, peaceful retirement and designing more pain and agony for you to enjoy. Bang the drums and sound the trumpets! The More of a Bad Thing expansion is here. And this

Easy Shipping

Quick Dispatch:

Your Plum Island Horror: More of a Bad Thing orders ship within 1-2 business days.

Delivery Options:

Standard: 3-7 business days
Fast: 2-3 business days
Express: 1-2 business days

Order Tracking:

You'll receive a tracking link by email once your Plum Island Horror: More of a Bad Thing ships.

Need Help?
Questions about Plum Island Horror: More of a Bad Thing, sizing, or delivery? We're just an email away.

Live Shipping Estimates:
Enter your location at checkout to see available shipping methods and costs for Plum Island Horror: More of a Bad Thing in your area.

Get Shipping Estimates

Country Zip/Postal Code

Exchange/Return Notes

We offer a 30-day return/exchange service after receiving.
Final sale items are not eligible for returns or exchanges.
To process your return/exchange, please contact us at [email protected]
Please click here for more details>>> Return & Exchange Policy

My dog is a heavy chewer so I don’t expect things to last long with him. But with that being said, he actually doesn’t go too hard on these stuffies and loves each and every one. Will they stand up to aggressive chewing? No they are stuffies. But for this price and for the quality, they are worth it for sure. Sometimes they don’t always squeak but I’m ok with that, because the constant squeaking can drive you crazy. I have a golden who can shove 3 of these in his big mouth but truly, one fits just fine. They are good sized for big dogs, it’s just that mine prefers to have his mouth stuffed like a chipmunk. He loves these stuffies and we will be ordering more for his endless toy box that I didn’t know I needed!

WAS THIS REVIEW HELPFUL?YesReportShare

Reviewed in the United States on November 12, 2025

Verified Purchase

J. Bergstrom

Bozeman, US

★★★★★ 4

Good for puppies or dogs with little to no teeth!

Set name: Stuffed Animal Dog Toy Set (5 Pcs)

Good for the most part. Definitely not made for a heavy chewer! My dog shredded all 5 plushies within a couple days. Lol She got a hold of 2 them the first night and we woke up to a plushie crime scene. Fluff was everywhere and the squeakers were in pieces in the middle. The toys were unrecognizable, and no one could possibly have identified their intended animal shapes. Our silly girl was laying next to the massacred toys with what could only be described as a prideful grin.

WAS THIS REVIEW HELPFUL?YesReportShare

Reviewed in the United States on December 28, 2025

Verified Purchase

Rush Woman

Charlottesville, US

★★★★★ 5

Great assortment to keep the dog running

Set name: Stuffed Animal Dog Toy Set (5 Pcs)

My Jack Russell Terrier mix is madly in love with these squeaky toys. Every morning when he gets up he demands to have at least 4 throws of these as part of his morning ritual now. He loves them, and they seem well sewn and will last him quite a long time (but he has only a couple teeth), and they are washable which this dog mom likes. A good investment for my JRT mix.

WAS THIS REVIEW HELPFUL?YesReportShare

Reviewed in the United States on March 23, 2026